All our flavors · Baked to order

Dairy-Free Gourmet Cookies, Baked Fresh

Big, 5 oz, chef-made cookies with crisp edges and soft centers, baked to order and shipped nationwide within 24 hours (arrives in 3–5 business days). No butter, no milk and never too sweet. Pick a box below, then fill it with any mix of our flavors.

5 oz cookieBakery-size, every flavor
Dairy-freeNo butter, no milk. Ever.
Baked to orderBaked after you order
Never too sweetBalanced, not sugary
Kosher-certified
Start with a box

Pick a size. Then the flavors.

Cookies ship in boxes. The Baker's Dozen gets you 13 for the price of 12.

The Six

$426 cookies

A thank-you, a taster, a treat for you.

or pick your flavors
Most generous

Baker's Dozen

$8413 cookies, pay for 12

The one most people order. Add a Six to ship free.

or pick your flavors
Ships free

The Party Box

$16826 cookies, pay for 24

Two Baker's Dozens. For the office, game night or a full house.

or pick your flavors
The menu

Our cookies. All of them big.

Build a box

Oatmeal Spice

Oats, cinnamon, warm spice, vanilla glaze

5 oz
Dairy-free
From $42 / box
1

Midnight Bite

Black cocoa, chocolate glaze, brownie bits

5 oz
Dairy-free
From $42 / box
1

Lotus

Lotus caramel, warm cinnamon

5 oz
Dairy-free
From $42 / box
1

The Original

Chocolate chunk, crisp edges, soft middle

5 oz
Dairy-free
From $42 / box
1

Cookies & Cream

Chocolate sandwich-cookie chunks, vanilla drizzle

5 oz
Dairy-free
From $42 / box
1

S'Mores

Belgian chocolate, graham, torched marshmallow

5 oz
Dairy-free
From $42 / box
1

Sea Salt Caramel

Belgian chocolate, caramel toffee, flaky sea salt

5 oz
Dairy-free
From $42 / box
1

Gone Bananas

Banana bread, vanilla drizzle, crumble

5 oz
Dairy-free
From $42 / box
1

Pumpkin Spice Snickerdoodle

Pumpkin spice, rolled in cinnamon sugar

5 oz
Dairy-free
From $42 / box
1

Maple Pecan

Maple dough, toasted pecans

5 oz
Dairy-free
From $42 / box
1

Cookies ship in boxes of 6, 13 or 26.

About our cookies

Gourmet cookies, minus the dairy.

Every Cake My Cookies cookie is made by a chef, baked to order and shipped within 24 hours so it never sits on a shelf. We bake big, 5 oz each: crisp edges, soft centers and real chunks of chocolate and marshmallow.

Every flavor is dairy-free (no butter, no milk) and built for balance, not a sugar rush.

Questions

Are your cookies dairy-free?

Yes. No butter and no milk in any flavor, and nobody guesses.

How sweet are they?

Not very, on purpose. We bake for balance, not a sugar rush: deep chocolate, toasted edges and a pinch of salt.

How fresh do they arrive?

We bake to order and ship within 24 hours. Boxes arrive in 3–5 business days and stay fresh for 7 days, or freeze them for later.

Do you ship nationwide?

Yes, anywhere in the US by USPS or UPS with tracking. Orders over $100 ship free.

Are your cookies kosher?

Yes, as a bonus: every cookie is certified kosher (parve) by Kosher Miami.

Baker's Dozen
13 cookies · $84
Build a box