Four Cake My Cookies cookies, one broken open, on parchment
13for the price of 12
Baked to order · Shipped nationwide

Dairy-free. Never too sweet.

Big, chef-made gourmet cookies with crisp edges and soft centers. Baked fresh, delivered anywhere. Nobody will guess what's missing.

5 oz, bakery-size cookiesShipped within 24 hoursFree shipping $100+
5 oz cookieBakery-size, every flavor
Dairy-freeNo butter, no milk. Ever.
Baked to orderBaked after you order
Never too sweetBalanced, not sugary
Kosher-certified
A spread of Cake My Cookies flavors on parchment with an open kraft box
+1on us
The hero box

The Baker's Dozen.

13 cookies. You pay for 12. That's how bakers used to do it, and it's how we do it.

$8413 cookies · $6.46 each

  • Pick any mix of our flavors, or let the chef choose
  • The 13th cookie is always on us
  • Add a 6-box and the whole order ships free
Build your Baker's Dozen
Pick your box

Three sizes. Zero guesswork.

Every box is baked the day it ships and packed by hand.

The Six

$426 cookies

A thank-you, a taster, a treat for you.

or pick your flavors
Most generous

Baker's Dozen

$8413 cookies, pay for 12

The one most people order. Add a Six to ship free.

or pick your flavors
Ships free

The Party Box

$16826 cookies, pay for 24

Two Baker's Dozens. For the office, game night or a full house.

or pick your flavors
The menu

Our cookies. All of them big.

The Original

Chocolate chunk, crisp edges, soft middle

5 oz
Dairy-free
1

Midnight Bite

Black cocoa, chocolate glaze, brownie bits

5 oz
Dairy-free
1

Lotus

Lotus caramel, warm cinnamon

5 oz
Dairy-free
1

Oatmeal Spice

Oats, cinnamon, warm spice, vanilla glaze

5 oz
Dairy-free
1

Cookies & Cream

Chocolate sandwich-cookie chunks, vanilla drizzle

5 oz
Dairy-free
1

S'Mores

Belgian chocolate, graham, torched marshmallow

5 oz
Dairy-free
1

Gone Bananas

Banana bread, vanilla drizzle, crumble

5 oz
Dairy-free
1
Oatmeal Spice
Falllimited run
Flavor of the month

Hey there, fall.

Oatmeal Spice is back for sweater weather: soft oats, cinnamon and a thin vanilla glaze. Never too sweet, baked to order and dairy-free.

CinnamonRolled oatsVanilla glaze
1
See the cookie →
Midnight Bite broken open
Chef-level, not candy-level

Break one open. Taste the chocolate, not the sugar.

Most cookie brands compete on who can pile on more frosting. We bake for balance: deep chocolate, toasted edges and a pinch of salt.

Shop Midnight Bite
From our oven to their door

Baked the day it ships.

1

You order, we bake

Nothing sits on a shelf. Your box goes into the oven after you check out.

2

Baked & shipped within 24 hours

USPS or UPS, tracked. Your order leaves our kitchen the day it's baked, so cookies never sit on a shelf.

3

Arrives in 3–5 business days, fresh for 7 days

Or freeze them for later. Warm one at 350°F for 3 minutes and it tastes like it just came out of the oven.

A hand lifting one wrapped cookie out of the kraft box
Gifts & occasions

A box for every reason.

Dairy-free, never too sweet and baked to order: one box works for the whole client list, the whole family and the whole party.

Baker's Dozen
13 cookies · $84
Build a box